0 comment Thursday, July 24, 2014 | admin
Lately we are told frequently by the media and by our political classes that we, Americans, are 'a nation of immigrants.' A google search on this phrase produces some 46,800,000 hits.
Yet how true is this phrase? It seems to imply, among other things, that America has no distinct character or culture; it is merely a tabula rasa, a blank slate upon which anyone is invited to come and write whatever he wishes. Each successive wave of newcomers, then, would superimpose his own culture and customs, and whichever group was most numerous would succeed in remaking America to their specifications. This seems to be the goal of the latest groups of immigrants: not to join an existing America, but to reshape America.
There is an implication also that America is strictly a creation of all the colorful 'melting-pot' immigrants; it is lately claimed that 'immigrants built America', or that they 'made America great.' This diminishes the contribution of the original colonists and settlers of America.
Reading the words of English philosopher Edmund Burke from the year 1775 tells us something about the character of the American people as they existed then. In his 'Speech on Conciliation With the Colonies', Burke said:
"In this character of the Americans a love of freedom is the predominating feature which marks and distinguishes the whole: and as an ardent is always a jealous affection, your colonies become suspicious, restive, and intractable, whenever they see the least attempt to wrest from them by force, or shuffle from them by chicane, what they think is the only advantage worth living for. This fierce spirit of liberty is stronger in the English colonies, probably, than in any other people of the earth...First, the people of the colonies are descendants of Englishmen. England, Sir, is a nation which still, I hope, respects, and formerly adored, her freedom. The colonists emigrated from you when this part of your character was most predominant; and they took this bias and direction the moment they parted fro your hands. They are therefore not only devoted to liberty, but to liberty according to English ideas and on English principles...The colonies draw from you, as with their life-blood, these ideas and principles."
Remember, Burke's description is of an America before the days of mass immigration. It would seem, then, that the main characteristics of the American spirit were present even before this country declared independence from England. And whatever else characterizes America, surely most people would agree that the love of freedom and the 'fierce spirit of liberty' was the contribution of the earliest colonists to America. America was a great country because of these high ideals, and later generations of immigrants became Americans by adopting these ideals and the commitment to defend liberty. All true Americans, regardless of national origin, share these traits with the early English colonists. To immigrate here, in earlier eras, implied acceptance of these American ideals.
Without the distinctive contributions of the original English settlers and their particular character, without the ideals which shaped the founding of this country, America could never have become the magnet which drew the later waves of immigrants. To say that the immigrants 'made this country what it is today' is to diminish the role of the original colonists and Founders.
Our current Politically Correct orthodoxy has decided that the Founding Fathers were just 'dead white males', not worthy of respect or deserving of any credit. In some kind of perverse upside-down hierarchy, immigrants are the true makers of this country, and newer immigrants are accorded more status than the original settlers of this country and their descendants. Our founding heroes have been disparaged and removed from their rightful place, while new arrivals, even those who entered illegally, are treated with deference.
Perhaps we are now a nation of immigrants, or at least a nation for immigrants.
Yet how true is this phrase? It seems to imply, among other things, that America has no distinct character or culture; it is merely a tabula rasa, a blank slate upon which anyone is invited to come and write whatever he wishes. Each successive wave of newcomers, then, would superimpose his own culture and customs, and whichever group was most numerous would succeed in remaking America to their specifications. This seems to be the goal of the latest groups of immigrants: not to join an existing America, but to reshape America.
There is an implication also that America is strictly a creation of all the colorful 'melting-pot' immigrants; it is lately claimed that 'immigrants built America', or that they 'made America great.' This diminishes the contribution of the original colonists and settlers of America.
Reading the words of English philosopher Edmund Burke from the year 1775 tells us something about the character of the American people as they existed then. In his 'Speech on Conciliation With the Colonies', Burke said:
"In this character of the Americans a love of freedom is the predominating feature which marks and distinguishes the whole: and as an ardent is always a jealous affection, your colonies become suspicious, restive, and intractable, whenever they see the least attempt to wrest from them by force, or shuffle from them by chicane, what they think is the only advantage worth living for. This fierce spirit of liberty is stronger in the English colonies, probably, than in any other people of the earth...First, the people of the colonies are descendants of Englishmen. England, Sir, is a nation which still, I hope, respects, and formerly adored, her freedom. The colonists emigrated from you when this part of your character was most predominant; and they took this bias and direction the moment they parted fro your hands. They are therefore not only devoted to liberty, but to liberty according to English ideas and on English principles...The colonies draw from you, as with their life-blood, these ideas and principles."
Remember, Burke's description is of an America before the days of mass immigration. It would seem, then, that the main characteristics of the American spirit were present even before this country declared independence from England. And whatever else characterizes America, surely most people would agree that the love of freedom and the 'fierce spirit of liberty' was the contribution of the earliest colonists to America. America was a great country because of these high ideals, and later generations of immigrants became Americans by adopting these ideals and the commitment to defend liberty. All true Americans, regardless of national origin, share these traits with the early English colonists. To immigrate here, in earlier eras, implied acceptance of these American ideals.
Without the distinctive contributions of the original English settlers and their particular character, without the ideals which shaped the founding of this country, America could never have become the magnet which drew the later waves of immigrants. To say that the immigrants 'made this country what it is today' is to diminish the role of the original colonists and Founders.
Our current Politically Correct orthodoxy has decided that the Founding Fathers were just 'dead white males', not worthy of respect or deserving of any credit. In some kind of perverse upside-down hierarchy, immigrants are the true makers of this country, and newer immigrants are accorded more status than the original settlers of this country and their descendants. Our founding heroes have been disparaged and removed from their rightful place, while new arrivals, even those who entered illegally, are treated with deference.
Perhaps we are now a nation of immigrants, or at least a nation for immigrants.
Labels: Immigrants, Nation
0 comment Tuesday, May 20, 2014 | admin
Reading the news media and listening to our pandering politicians on the subject of immigration, legal or illegal, it's becoming apparent that the history of America is being rewritten at a furious pace lately. During the last two weeks with all the discussion of amnesty and all the agitation in the streets of our cities, the rhetoric has been hot and heavy.
The phrase du jour is 'a nation of immigrants'. And it's obvious that the term 'immigrant' is now expanded to include illegal invaders as well as those who enter this county lawfully. And it's clear that somehow, the emphasis has shifted so that the immigrant, illegal or legal, is now the apotheosis of the American ideal. The immigrant is that most American of all Americans, paradoxically. Those of us whose roots here go back far enough that we no longer identify with our ancestral countries are somehow less valued, suddenly, than those who stealthily entered across the Arizona desert or the Rio Grande last week or last night. They are the heroic new Americans who represent the true meaning of America. The glowing stereotype of the brave, noble, plucky immigrant builds on the old Ellis Island cliches of the huddled masses with tears in their eyes, enriching America by their presence.
Peggy Noonan, in her gushing column in the Wall Street Journal, positively swoons over the sainted immigrants she loves. Fine, Peggy; I am happy you are infatuated with the illegals marching in your city, but your rose-colored glasses are obscuring your view.
Peggy is happy that the illegals purportedly share her religion; they are Catholic, so we are told, and so is she. Because of her Irish immigrant origins, she somehow feels like one of the immigrants. Peggy refers to the Irish as 'her people'. Peggy, are not Americans your people?
I don't know how recent Peggy's immigrant origins are; did her people immigrate here two generations back? Three? How long does it take before one identifies as an American only, and not as an immigrant? I am sorry to say that many, many of the people who have a soft approach to the border problem are sympathetic because they identify with their immigrant roots more than with their country of birth. They are actually walking arguments in favor of restricting immigration, because recent immigrant origins seem to predispose one to a romanticized, sentimental rapport with the illegals.
I realize there are exceptions; there are immigrants and children of immigrants whose allegiances are 100% American;
Michelle Malkin and Yeh Ling-ling are two examples that immediately come to mind. But there are, apparently, many more whose recent immigrant origins color their views on the border problem.
Peggy Noonan, with her pink-and-fluffy view of immigrants, represents a sentimentalized worldview which detracts from our ability to defend ourselves as a nation. Our country and our culture have become excessively sentimentalized and feminized; this country needs to reassert its more masculine, confident, hard-headed side; we are in jeopardy, and softheartedness will only weaken us further.
The phrase du jour is 'a nation of immigrants'. And it's obvious that the term 'immigrant' is now expanded to include illegal invaders as well as those who enter this county lawfully. And it's clear that somehow, the emphasis has shifted so that the immigrant, illegal or legal, is now the apotheosis of the American ideal. The immigrant is that most American of all Americans, paradoxically. Those of us whose roots here go back far enough that we no longer identify with our ancestral countries are somehow less valued, suddenly, than those who stealthily entered across the Arizona desert or the Rio Grande last week or last night. They are the heroic new Americans who represent the true meaning of America. The glowing stereotype of the brave, noble, plucky immigrant builds on the old Ellis Island cliches of the huddled masses with tears in their eyes, enriching America by their presence.
Peggy Noonan, in her gushing column in the Wall Street Journal, positively swoons over the sainted immigrants she loves. Fine, Peggy; I am happy you are infatuated with the illegals marching in your city, but your rose-colored glasses are obscuring your view.
Peggy is happy that the illegals purportedly share her religion; they are Catholic, so we are told, and so is she. Because of her Irish immigrant origins, she somehow feels like one of the immigrants. Peggy refers to the Irish as 'her people'. Peggy, are not Americans your people?
I don't know how recent Peggy's immigrant origins are; did her people immigrate here two generations back? Three? How long does it take before one identifies as an American only, and not as an immigrant? I am sorry to say that many, many of the people who have a soft approach to the border problem are sympathetic because they identify with their immigrant roots more than with their country of birth. They are actually walking arguments in favor of restricting immigration, because recent immigrant origins seem to predispose one to a romanticized, sentimental rapport with the illegals.
I realize there are exceptions; there are immigrants and children of immigrants whose allegiances are 100% American;
Michelle Malkin and Yeh Ling-ling are two examples that immediately come to mind. But there are, apparently, many more whose recent immigrant origins color their views on the border problem.
Peggy Noonan, with her pink-and-fluffy view of immigrants, represents a sentimentalized worldview which detracts from our ability to defend ourselves as a nation. Our country and our culture have become excessively sentimentalized and feminized; this country needs to reassert its more masculine, confident, hard-headed side; we are in jeopardy, and softheartedness will only weaken us further.
Labels: Exaltation, Immigrants
