0 comment Wednesday, October 1, 2014 | admin
Ideology.
Or at least it should be.
Daniel Larison writes:
In any case, I don�t care which side of the war debate people are on�to turn against your brother or cousin or friend because of Mr. Bush�s War is to let the hegemonists win two unjust victories, as they have managed to sever real, healthy, living bonds between two kinsmen or friends by convincing everyone involved that some lousy political question is more important than their affinities and loyalties to one another. This is to elevate either loyalty or opposition to the state above loyalty to your own, which should almost always take precedence (I would say always, but there are probably exceptional cases that aren�t springing to mind right now that would make such an absolute statement seem a little crazy). Each time someone puts politics ahead of his blood and his people, the horrid ideologues win another triumph. If they can divide us against our own flesh, they can conquer any and all of us.
If I had a brother (I don�t�I am an only child), I would hate to think that I would ever turn against him over some political quarrel, even one pertaining to a serious matter of war. Obviously, I am just about as opposed to this war as anyone can be, but to choose either the War Party or the antiwar folks over your own flesh and blood reveals the far more troubling corruption of our society. I realise that this would hardly be the first time in our history that relatives and friends have taken opposite sides of a political quarrel, but it seems to me that we may be able to locate the ultimate cause of the repeated defeats of local and particular loyalties at the hands of people spouting universalist and idealist claptrap in this tendency of some people to prefer their "cause" over their kindred in the flesh.
Here on this blog and elsewhere, I've discussed the subject of how divided Americans are these days along political lines; it seems, from a traditionalist point of view, that politics (or ideology, in the case of liberals) has almost supplanted the more primal, natural bonds that used to predominate. For instance, as our national culture and identity have been considerably weakened by our liberal culture, and as our kinship/ethnic/racial ties of blood are now being discredited if not made thought-crimes, people identify on the basis of political orientation, and these allegiances assume a strength which they never possessed in the past.
When I was a child, the Republican Party and the Democrat Party were not the bitter enemies they have become now; people differed on certain points of principle, and sometimes joked about the adherents of the other party, but in our present time, these differences have become increasingly bitter and divisive. Members of both parties seem to see each other as The Enemy, while they in many cases bear no such intense animosity towards other nations or peoples. Liberals in particular will happily turn on their own people and side with enemies. Republicans don't go to that extreme, usually, although I have had the 'pleasure' of having a rabid Republican tell me that most of the Hispanics he knew were 'better Americans' than I am. So yes, we have ideology-driven Republicans, too.
The growth of the fanatical devotion to party and ideology coincided with the decline in our national pride, and our ethnic/racial/kinship ties. Is it just a matter of ideology filling the vacuum which was left when it became unfashionable or 'bigoted' to be proud of one's blood heritage and lineage?
Even though many liberals hold the fanatical belief that each of us can create himself, that we are all 'protean' personalities who can be shaped and reinvented at will by ourselves, I think we all have a deep need to belong, and to know our place in the world, to know that we are part of something larger than ourselves. We also have a need, I think, to feel linked to the past and the future, and our family ties and lineages fill that need. We thus feel connected to our ancestors and to our progeny. The fact that many liberals see the past as irrelevant except to be mined as a source of grievances and injustices, and their ancestors are thought of as backward, unenlightened, and bigoted, is a very isolating thing. Again, many liberals choose not to reproduce until later in life, if at all. I have liberal friends, a couple who made a choice, when they were young, not to have children. These people seem to feel disconnected from both past and future, just free-floating individuals. Their main ties to other people are via their liberal ideology: they attend a liberal, activist church and participate in 'peace and justice' causes. I believe most of their friends share their political beliefs. I'm an exception because I have since 'left the left'. I have changed my political views, while they have not. It has strained our relationship, because I know that my views are now intolerable to them, and so we have to avoid anything remotely political or controversial in our conversations. I can't really speak my mind to them any longer, and this makes for a very superficial friendship.
Similarly with some liberal relatives; we have had some heated exchanges on political matters, which usually end up with offense taken and hurt feelings on their side. So far, however, blood is thicker than water, and so we work around our points of disagreement, usually by my biting my tongue and holding back what I might like to say.
In my family, however, even among the liberal members, we hold family and kin in high regard, and we really believe that blood is thicker than water. This holds true with my liberal friends so far, too, although I wonder if I fully spoke my mind, if they wouldn't excommunicate me from their lives.
Some people, bless their hearts, are not that politically minded, and are often too apathetic to get exercised over the latest outrages in the news. But these people, too, have somewhat adopted the liberal mindset which prevails in our society: they see themselves as individuals, not as part of a continuity of the generations, or of our historic culture. Often these kinds of people are non-religious as well as non-political. These people often define themselves in even shallower terms than the ideologues, identifying themselves by the consumer choices they make: wearing a certain style of clothing, driving a certain make of car, living in a certain kind of community, or following a certain sports team or teams avidly,
The fact that our society is now populated to such a degree by the apathetic, unaffiliated people is a problem in itself, too. However I wonder if these people might at least be induced to care about something beyond themselves, and the present moment, given the right circumstances? I think everybody has a hunger for something beyond themselves; even the more nihilistic and hedonistic people. They may not know what they are looking for, but there is a vacuum in their lives.
But those who have filled the vacuum with pernicious ideology like liberalism are more of a problem; they are the true believers, and they are the most intolerant, despite their pretensions to tolerance. The liberals, and I include even the right-liberals and libertarians who believe in the Proposition Nation and multiculturalism and PC, are absolutely closed-minded.
Does anybody ever 'come back' from liberalism? Is their life after liberalism? At one time, I would have said yes; people can be converted. I don't know if I am a typical example of a liberal; I was raised, as most of my age-group, in a very traditional, conservative America, and in a large, extended, loving family, in the pre-PC South where kinship, Christianity, and heritage were honored. So I may not be a typical ex-liberal.
Unfortunately I have seen a lot of 'ex'-liberals and leftists who claim to have seen the light and become conservative, but they have been incompletely converted if at all, and still hold to very liberal-to-libertarian ideas on social issues like marriage, homosexuality, drug use, and abortion. On issues like immigration and multiculturalism, they still hold their 1960s ideas intact. Feminism is still fiercely defended among many Republican women.
Sometimes in considering this question of ideology trumping all, I am reminded of the War Between the States, or the Civil War, if you insist. Was that a question of ideology overriding blood ties and kinship? Certainly there was an ideological element to the War, and we have all heard the cliches about families in which brother fought brother, one in a Confederate uniform and one in the Union blue. I think those cases may have been rarer than we are led to believe; most families knew where their allegiances were. And the fact is, the South and the North were divided from the beginning, with most of the South descending from the Cavalier colonists who came to Jamestown, and the later waves of Scots-Irish, while the North represented Yankee descendants of the original Puritan colonists and later waves of ethnic immigrants. During my childhood, spending time with my mother's Yankee family and my Texas family, the cultural differences were striking, even then. I suspect the cultural differences were even more marked a century earlier, and despite all the homogenizing of America in the 20th century, the differences remain. There were in a sense two different nations, North and South, and they were held together based more on ideological ties than on the deeper, more primal blood and culture ties. So far, history has tended to show that a country can't be held together forever based on the tenuous ties of ideology and 'propositions'.
Ideology, as Daniel Larison says, tends to be poison. And if America is further fragmented, with the introduction of ever more disparate people (thanks to liberal ideologues), the fragile ties of ideology won't be able to keep the tenuous 'proposition nation' together for long.
Or at least it should be.
Daniel Larison writes:
In any case, I don�t care which side of the war debate people are on�to turn against your brother or cousin or friend because of Mr. Bush�s War is to let the hegemonists win two unjust victories, as they have managed to sever real, healthy, living bonds between two kinsmen or friends by convincing everyone involved that some lousy political question is more important than their affinities and loyalties to one another. This is to elevate either loyalty or opposition to the state above loyalty to your own, which should almost always take precedence (I would say always, but there are probably exceptional cases that aren�t springing to mind right now that would make such an absolute statement seem a little crazy). Each time someone puts politics ahead of his blood and his people, the horrid ideologues win another triumph. If they can divide us against our own flesh, they can conquer any and all of us.
If I had a brother (I don�t�I am an only child), I would hate to think that I would ever turn against him over some political quarrel, even one pertaining to a serious matter of war. Obviously, I am just about as opposed to this war as anyone can be, but to choose either the War Party or the antiwar folks over your own flesh and blood reveals the far more troubling corruption of our society. I realise that this would hardly be the first time in our history that relatives and friends have taken opposite sides of a political quarrel, but it seems to me that we may be able to locate the ultimate cause of the repeated defeats of local and particular loyalties at the hands of people spouting universalist and idealist claptrap in this tendency of some people to prefer their "cause" over their kindred in the flesh.
Here on this blog and elsewhere, I've discussed the subject of how divided Americans are these days along political lines; it seems, from a traditionalist point of view, that politics (or ideology, in the case of liberals) has almost supplanted the more primal, natural bonds that used to predominate. For instance, as our national culture and identity have been considerably weakened by our liberal culture, and as our kinship/ethnic/racial ties of blood are now being discredited if not made thought-crimes, people identify on the basis of political orientation, and these allegiances assume a strength which they never possessed in the past.
When I was a child, the Republican Party and the Democrat Party were not the bitter enemies they have become now; people differed on certain points of principle, and sometimes joked about the adherents of the other party, but in our present time, these differences have become increasingly bitter and divisive. Members of both parties seem to see each other as The Enemy, while they in many cases bear no such intense animosity towards other nations or peoples. Liberals in particular will happily turn on their own people and side with enemies. Republicans don't go to that extreme, usually, although I have had the 'pleasure' of having a rabid Republican tell me that most of the Hispanics he knew were 'better Americans' than I am. So yes, we have ideology-driven Republicans, too.
The growth of the fanatical devotion to party and ideology coincided with the decline in our national pride, and our ethnic/racial/kinship ties. Is it just a matter of ideology filling the vacuum which was left when it became unfashionable or 'bigoted' to be proud of one's blood heritage and lineage?
Even though many liberals hold the fanatical belief that each of us can create himself, that we are all 'protean' personalities who can be shaped and reinvented at will by ourselves, I think we all have a deep need to belong, and to know our place in the world, to know that we are part of something larger than ourselves. We also have a need, I think, to feel linked to the past and the future, and our family ties and lineages fill that need. We thus feel connected to our ancestors and to our progeny. The fact that many liberals see the past as irrelevant except to be mined as a source of grievances and injustices, and their ancestors are thought of as backward, unenlightened, and bigoted, is a very isolating thing. Again, many liberals choose not to reproduce until later in life, if at all. I have liberal friends, a couple who made a choice, when they were young, not to have children. These people seem to feel disconnected from both past and future, just free-floating individuals. Their main ties to other people are via their liberal ideology: they attend a liberal, activist church and participate in 'peace and justice' causes. I believe most of their friends share their political beliefs. I'm an exception because I have since 'left the left'. I have changed my political views, while they have not. It has strained our relationship, because I know that my views are now intolerable to them, and so we have to avoid anything remotely political or controversial in our conversations. I can't really speak my mind to them any longer, and this makes for a very superficial friendship.
Similarly with some liberal relatives; we have had some heated exchanges on political matters, which usually end up with offense taken and hurt feelings on their side. So far, however, blood is thicker than water, and so we work around our points of disagreement, usually by my biting my tongue and holding back what I might like to say.
In my family, however, even among the liberal members, we hold family and kin in high regard, and we really believe that blood is thicker than water. This holds true with my liberal friends so far, too, although I wonder if I fully spoke my mind, if they wouldn't excommunicate me from their lives.
Some people, bless their hearts, are not that politically minded, and are often too apathetic to get exercised over the latest outrages in the news. But these people, too, have somewhat adopted the liberal mindset which prevails in our society: they see themselves as individuals, not as part of a continuity of the generations, or of our historic culture. Often these kinds of people are non-religious as well as non-political. These people often define themselves in even shallower terms than the ideologues, identifying themselves by the consumer choices they make: wearing a certain style of clothing, driving a certain make of car, living in a certain kind of community, or following a certain sports team or teams avidly,
The fact that our society is now populated to such a degree by the apathetic, unaffiliated people is a problem in itself, too. However I wonder if these people might at least be induced to care about something beyond themselves, and the present moment, given the right circumstances? I think everybody has a hunger for something beyond themselves; even the more nihilistic and hedonistic people. They may not know what they are looking for, but there is a vacuum in their lives.
But those who have filled the vacuum with pernicious ideology like liberalism are more of a problem; they are the true believers, and they are the most intolerant, despite their pretensions to tolerance. The liberals, and I include even the right-liberals and libertarians who believe in the Proposition Nation and multiculturalism and PC, are absolutely closed-minded.
Does anybody ever 'come back' from liberalism? Is their life after liberalism? At one time, I would have said yes; people can be converted. I don't know if I am a typical example of a liberal; I was raised, as most of my age-group, in a very traditional, conservative America, and in a large, extended, loving family, in the pre-PC South where kinship, Christianity, and heritage were honored. So I may not be a typical ex-liberal.
Unfortunately I have seen a lot of 'ex'-liberals and leftists who claim to have seen the light and become conservative, but they have been incompletely converted if at all, and still hold to very liberal-to-libertarian ideas on social issues like marriage, homosexuality, drug use, and abortion. On issues like immigration and multiculturalism, they still hold their 1960s ideas intact. Feminism is still fiercely defended among many Republican women.
Sometimes in considering this question of ideology trumping all, I am reminded of the War Between the States, or the Civil War, if you insist. Was that a question of ideology overriding blood ties and kinship? Certainly there was an ideological element to the War, and we have all heard the cliches about families in which brother fought brother, one in a Confederate uniform and one in the Union blue. I think those cases may have been rarer than we are led to believe; most families knew where their allegiances were. And the fact is, the South and the North were divided from the beginning, with most of the South descending from the Cavalier colonists who came to Jamestown, and the later waves of Scots-Irish, while the North represented Yankee descendants of the original Puritan colonists and later waves of ethnic immigrants. During my childhood, spending time with my mother's Yankee family and my Texas family, the cultural differences were striking, even then. I suspect the cultural differences were even more marked a century earlier, and despite all the homogenizing of America in the 20th century, the differences remain. There were in a sense two different nations, North and South, and they were held together based more on ideological ties than on the deeper, more primal blood and culture ties. So far, history has tended to show that a country can't be held together forever based on the tenuous ties of ideology and 'propositions'.
Ideology, as Daniel Larison says, tends to be poison. And if America is further fragmented, with the introduction of ever more disparate people (thanks to liberal ideologues), the fragile ties of ideology won't be able to keep the tenuous 'proposition nation' together for long.
Labels: American Culture, Ideology, Liberalism, Politics, Proposition Nation
0 comment Tuesday, July 15, 2014 | admin
What is America to me?
A name, a map, or a flag I see;
A certain word, democracy.
What is America to me?
The above lines are the introduction to the song "The House I Live In" which many people know as a song sung by Frank Sinatra in a short subject made during the War years.
At Dispatches from the Hogtown Front, the blogger Hyphenated Canadian asks what Canada means.
That provoked some thought on my part about America, and about what it means to be an American.
So I've been pondering Americanness.
This blog came into being because of my sense that America, and the American way of life, was vanishing. Further, it was not vanishing as a result of some inevitable natural force, but by the loss of our old ways of being and thinking.
But in light of all that has been happening in our world in recent years, with millions of people from every corner of the world arriving in America, and claiming a right to her, I wonder what Americanness means? Is there such a thing, in an absolute sense, if anybody and everybody who shows up here can be an American simply by acquiring a piece of paper?
So what is America?
To me, it's a one-of-a-kind country which can never be recreated anywhere else on earth, should it fall to those who are doing their best to topple it now. America is an irreplaceable country. Now if it were a 'proposition', an abstraction, a set of words on a parchment, even those great words written by my long-ago kinsman, Thomas Jefferson, then it would be reproducible anywhere and everywhere.
If America is just the Constitution and the admittedly great ideas embodied therein, why has not some group of people in another corner of the world not taken that document and used it to create their own America for themselves? The founding documents of our country, with all their great and lofty ideals and principles, have been freely available to all who want to glean the wisdom therein. Why has nobody acted on that blueprint and created America on their own soil? If it is an 'idea' then it is sort of a franchise; we could set up Americas everywhere, like we open McDonald's restaurants everywhere, purveying Big Macs and fries. I hear that even in China, you can find a McDonald's burger. If we can franchise American fast food, why not American democracy?
Apparently that is the idea behind our being in Iraq: we are trying to establish a franchise for Jeffersonian democracy there. But still, even though the great ideas that supposedly constitute America are freely available for the taking and applying, nobody has made another America.
Do you think it might be that America, and the ideas which were so instrumental in her founding, were something peculiarly Western European, specifically British? Something which grew not out of nowhere, but from a long tradition which began hundreds of years earlier in England? And that England, and the people who made that country, made her the kind of country she was because of their unique character as a people?
Is it any accident that Britain has shared many of our longstanding traditions and ideals?
And is it accidental that our form of government has not taken root in much of the world?
Even many of the advanced countries that we think of as 'free' or 'democratic' are not exactly like America in their understanding of freedom; nobody has reproduced what we have here.
I think it's obvious that America is not merely an idea, or a set of ideas; America is a specific place, but it is merely a manifestation of the mind and the spirit of the people who first settled and shaped this place. And it may be that only Americans can truly understand and apply our system. I have seen no convincing evidence otherwise.
The liberals among us try to deny that fact, because they fret that it isn't 'inclusive' enough, and that it will offend or exclude other groups of people or nations. So we continue in this fantasy that we can export our way of life like a commodity. And yes, you can certainly export material goods; people the world over can wear jeans, (once a uniquely American garment), or eat a Big Mac, drink a Coke, and watch Hollywood movies. They might acquire the material trappings of America, but they can't re-create America. And conversely, we can import half the world's population here to these shores -- and it looks like that's just what our government intends to do -- but you cannot make these people Americans just by dropping them down in Minneapolis or Lewiston, Maine. There is no magic quality in the air or soil that transforms foreign people into Americans just by their physical presence here.
People are not blank slates.
And the simpletons who insist that 'every other generation of immigrants became American, so what is the problem?' are blind to the fact that first, America has never, ever allowed in so many millions of immigrants in such a short time. Second, previous generations of immigrants were mostly of European Christian origin. The commonalities far outweighed the differences. Later, when many more exotic groups immigrated, they assimilated only with difficulty, and many have in fact not assimilated to this day, not completely. Many descendants of the later waves of immigrants are, unfortunately, among the most ardent advocates of mass Third World immigration and open borders now. So even though they may speak perfect American English, and be outwardly American, obviously their sympathies are with immigrants, and they seem to harbor a resentment towards old-stock Americans, whom they see as adversaries if not enemies. They may not acknowledge this (although some express it quite openly) but it is implicit in their words and actions.
These later immigrant descendants are often among the revisionist historians and academics who push the idea that America is 'a nation of immigrants', and more perversely, they teach that 'immigrants built America.' Or that 'immigrants made America great.' Another variation on this same theme is that 'slaves built America.'
The implication is that old-stock Americans, who settled this country and fought for independence and who built the already-great country to which later immigrants came, really did nothing; the Anglo-Americans were some kind of effete aristocrats who sat around while immigrants and slaves accomplished the task of building America.
But the fact is: Americans made America. The very ideas and ideals which contributed to the making of America may not have been developed and brought to fruition by any other people on earth; they came out of a specific Western European, Anglo-Protestant matrix. And all of this came into being before the waves of immigrants of the 19th and 20th and now the 21st century.
America has welcomed in people of various national origins, and some have been a better fit than others; the best fit has been with people who were close ethnic kin to the original settlers of this country. Other later immigrants from more disparate cultures assimilated slowly, and incompletely. But all who are able and willing to embrace this country with its existing, distinctive culture can be grafted into the American people. Not all, however, are able or willing.
There are certainly immigrants who have become thoroughly American. Such immigrants truly love America, identify with her and her way of life. And it is more than merely assenting to some abstract ideas; the Americanized immigrant embraces the American people, past and present, and identifies with America, her culture, her customs, her way of life. One noted example of an immigrant who truly understood America and embraced her fully was the late,lamented Balint Vaszonyi. Coming from Communist Hungary as he did, he truly appreciated the freedom he found here, and he had a mature understanding of the history and the character of America.
My late fellow-blogger 'Aussiegirl' was another who loved this country and valued it deeply.
Everybody who knows the history of America and who truly loves America understands the fragility of what we have here; it is something that is a rarity in the history of mankind, and to tamper with the very nature and character of this country in the name of some vast social engineering experiment is like doing experimental brain surgery on an unconsenting patient, moreover, on a patient who does not need surgery. The patient may well be killed for the sake of an unjustified experiment.
America has her problems, and what problems she has among her citizens are due to disparate groups of people, conflicting values and allegiances. So what is the plan by our elites? Bring in more and more disparate, incompatible people with conflicting values and allegiances, and open hostilities. Mix well, and wait for the explosion.
So what is an American today?
I am loath to say that we Americans are 300 million people without a country and an identity, but that seems to be the direction in which we are heading, into uncharted waters.
I know that there are still many of us, descendants of those 21,000 Englishmen in New England, and the 40-some thousand colonists in Virginia, who are still here. Our culture, which has come down to us from our fathers, is still holding on, though in critical condition. But what makes us American?
Americans, even those of us of the old stock, are hard to pin down, but if I had to sum up the old American character, I would say independent, skeptical, practical, and not easily ruled; tough, persevering, hardy. We are sometimes excessive; the Puritan and the hedonist struggle within us.
At the same time, we are generally hospitable, altruistic, and neighborly, and it is these qualities which are now maliciously being used against us. There is something especially reprehensible and low and base in taking advantage of people's kindness, generosity, and niceness, and that is what is being done now. Uncle Sam, sometimes known as Uncle Sugar, is now being played for Uncle Sucker.
But in general, I agree with the assessment of writer Mary Ellen Chase, from 53 years ago in an essay:
We Americans have since our beginnings been known for our self-reliance, for our gumption and common sense. We are, or at least we were, adventurers, and our history is the story of a game played against tremendous odds and gloriously won. Why not recall the tough moral fiber which made the winning possible?
We will need to find that tough moral fiber, that distinctively American gumption, because in the new game in which America finds herself, the odds against us are even more tremendous than they were back in 1776. But as Chase said, our history is one of winning, despite the odds.
A name, a map, or a flag I see;
A certain word, democracy.
What is America to me?
The above lines are the introduction to the song "The House I Live In" which many people know as a song sung by Frank Sinatra in a short subject made during the War years.
At Dispatches from the Hogtown Front, the blogger Hyphenated Canadian asks what Canada means.
That provoked some thought on my part about America, and about what it means to be an American.
So I've been pondering Americanness.
This blog came into being because of my sense that America, and the American way of life, was vanishing. Further, it was not vanishing as a result of some inevitable natural force, but by the loss of our old ways of being and thinking.
But in light of all that has been happening in our world in recent years, with millions of people from every corner of the world arriving in America, and claiming a right to her, I wonder what Americanness means? Is there such a thing, in an absolute sense, if anybody and everybody who shows up here can be an American simply by acquiring a piece of paper?
So what is America?
To me, it's a one-of-a-kind country which can never be recreated anywhere else on earth, should it fall to those who are doing their best to topple it now. America is an irreplaceable country. Now if it were a 'proposition', an abstraction, a set of words on a parchment, even those great words written by my long-ago kinsman, Thomas Jefferson, then it would be reproducible anywhere and everywhere.
If America is just the Constitution and the admittedly great ideas embodied therein, why has not some group of people in another corner of the world not taken that document and used it to create their own America for themselves? The founding documents of our country, with all their great and lofty ideals and principles, have been freely available to all who want to glean the wisdom therein. Why has nobody acted on that blueprint and created America on their own soil? If it is an 'idea' then it is sort of a franchise; we could set up Americas everywhere, like we open McDonald's restaurants everywhere, purveying Big Macs and fries. I hear that even in China, you can find a McDonald's burger. If we can franchise American fast food, why not American democracy?
Apparently that is the idea behind our being in Iraq: we are trying to establish a franchise for Jeffersonian democracy there. But still, even though the great ideas that supposedly constitute America are freely available for the taking and applying, nobody has made another America.
Do you think it might be that America, and the ideas which were so instrumental in her founding, were something peculiarly Western European, specifically British? Something which grew not out of nowhere, but from a long tradition which began hundreds of years earlier in England? And that England, and the people who made that country, made her the kind of country she was because of their unique character as a people?
Is it any accident that Britain has shared many of our longstanding traditions and ideals?
And is it accidental that our form of government has not taken root in much of the world?
Even many of the advanced countries that we think of as 'free' or 'democratic' are not exactly like America in their understanding of freedom; nobody has reproduced what we have here.
I think it's obvious that America is not merely an idea, or a set of ideas; America is a specific place, but it is merely a manifestation of the mind and the spirit of the people who first settled and shaped this place. And it may be that only Americans can truly understand and apply our system. I have seen no convincing evidence otherwise.
The liberals among us try to deny that fact, because they fret that it isn't 'inclusive' enough, and that it will offend or exclude other groups of people or nations. So we continue in this fantasy that we can export our way of life like a commodity. And yes, you can certainly export material goods; people the world over can wear jeans, (once a uniquely American garment), or eat a Big Mac, drink a Coke, and watch Hollywood movies. They might acquire the material trappings of America, but they can't re-create America. And conversely, we can import half the world's population here to these shores -- and it looks like that's just what our government intends to do -- but you cannot make these people Americans just by dropping them down in Minneapolis or Lewiston, Maine. There is no magic quality in the air or soil that transforms foreign people into Americans just by their physical presence here.
People are not blank slates.
And the simpletons who insist that 'every other generation of immigrants became American, so what is the problem?' are blind to the fact that first, America has never, ever allowed in so many millions of immigrants in such a short time. Second, previous generations of immigrants were mostly of European Christian origin. The commonalities far outweighed the differences. Later, when many more exotic groups immigrated, they assimilated only with difficulty, and many have in fact not assimilated to this day, not completely. Many descendants of the later waves of immigrants are, unfortunately, among the most ardent advocates of mass Third World immigration and open borders now. So even though they may speak perfect American English, and be outwardly American, obviously their sympathies are with immigrants, and they seem to harbor a resentment towards old-stock Americans, whom they see as adversaries if not enemies. They may not acknowledge this (although some express it quite openly) but it is implicit in their words and actions.
These later immigrant descendants are often among the revisionist historians and academics who push the idea that America is 'a nation of immigrants', and more perversely, they teach that 'immigrants built America.' Or that 'immigrants made America great.' Another variation on this same theme is that 'slaves built America.'
The implication is that old-stock Americans, who settled this country and fought for independence and who built the already-great country to which later immigrants came, really did nothing; the Anglo-Americans were some kind of effete aristocrats who sat around while immigrants and slaves accomplished the task of building America.
But the fact is: Americans made America. The very ideas and ideals which contributed to the making of America may not have been developed and brought to fruition by any other people on earth; they came out of a specific Western European, Anglo-Protestant matrix. And all of this came into being before the waves of immigrants of the 19th and 20th and now the 21st century.
America has welcomed in people of various national origins, and some have been a better fit than others; the best fit has been with people who were close ethnic kin to the original settlers of this country. Other later immigrants from more disparate cultures assimilated slowly, and incompletely. But all who are able and willing to embrace this country with its existing, distinctive culture can be grafted into the American people. Not all, however, are able or willing.
There are certainly immigrants who have become thoroughly American. Such immigrants truly love America, identify with her and her way of life. And it is more than merely assenting to some abstract ideas; the Americanized immigrant embraces the American people, past and present, and identifies with America, her culture, her customs, her way of life. One noted example of an immigrant who truly understood America and embraced her fully was the late,lamented Balint Vaszonyi. Coming from Communist Hungary as he did, he truly appreciated the freedom he found here, and he had a mature understanding of the history and the character of America.
My late fellow-blogger 'Aussiegirl' was another who loved this country and valued it deeply.
Everybody who knows the history of America and who truly loves America understands the fragility of what we have here; it is something that is a rarity in the history of mankind, and to tamper with the very nature and character of this country in the name of some vast social engineering experiment is like doing experimental brain surgery on an unconsenting patient, moreover, on a patient who does not need surgery. The patient may well be killed for the sake of an unjustified experiment.
America has her problems, and what problems she has among her citizens are due to disparate groups of people, conflicting values and allegiances. So what is the plan by our elites? Bring in more and more disparate, incompatible people with conflicting values and allegiances, and open hostilities. Mix well, and wait for the explosion.
So what is an American today?
I am loath to say that we Americans are 300 million people without a country and an identity, but that seems to be the direction in which we are heading, into uncharted waters.
I know that there are still many of us, descendants of those 21,000 Englishmen in New England, and the 40-some thousand colonists in Virginia, who are still here. Our culture, which has come down to us from our fathers, is still holding on, though in critical condition. But what makes us American?
Americans, even those of us of the old stock, are hard to pin down, but if I had to sum up the old American character, I would say independent, skeptical, practical, and not easily ruled; tough, persevering, hardy. We are sometimes excessive; the Puritan and the hedonist struggle within us.
At the same time, we are generally hospitable, altruistic, and neighborly, and it is these qualities which are now maliciously being used against us. There is something especially reprehensible and low and base in taking advantage of people's kindness, generosity, and niceness, and that is what is being done now. Uncle Sam, sometimes known as Uncle Sugar, is now being played for Uncle Sucker.
But in general, I agree with the assessment of writer Mary Ellen Chase, from 53 years ago in an essay:
We Americans have since our beginnings been known for our self-reliance, for our gumption and common sense. We are, or at least we were, adventurers, and our history is the story of a game played against tremendous odds and gloriously won. Why not recall the tough moral fiber which made the winning possible?
We will need to find that tough moral fiber, that distinctively American gumption, because in the new game in which America finds herself, the odds against us are even more tremendous than they were back in 1776. But as Chase said, our history is one of winning, despite the odds.
Labels: American Culture, American History, Ideology, Immigration
